The Neuromuscular Disease Network for Canada

funder-logos_nmd4c

Letter to provincial governments regarding SMA therapy outcome measures

The landscape of disease-modifying therapies for spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) in Canada is rapidly changing. Nusinursen (Spinraza), an antisense oligonucleotide, is currently approved for children and, more recently, adults. Two others are currently under review by Health Canada: onasemnogene abeparvovec-xioi (Zolgensma), a gene replacement for children under age 2, and RG 7916 (Risdiplam), a splice modifier.

With these new therapies coming on the scene, it is important to monitor their effectiveness and to collect evidence to help determine which therapy should be chosen for any given patient. However, the current provincial government monitoring requirements are too frequent and there is significant variability between the provinces.

A group of Canadian neuromuscular disease specialists, most of whom are involved in NMD4C, have written a letter to the provincial governments outlining their concerns and recommending an alternative timeline for outcome measurements in patients receiving the therapies.

 

The full letter is not yet available; it will be published in the Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences HERE. In the meantime, you can read our summary below.

 

Written by: Victoria Hodgkinson (NMD4C collaborator) and Kerri Schellenberg (NMD4C member)

Reviewed and approved by: Kristine Chapman, Aaron Izenberg (NMD4C member), Hanns Lochmüller (NMD4C lead investigator), Colleen O’Connell, Erin K. O’Ferrall, Maryam Oskoui (NMD4C investigator), Gerald Pfeffer (NMD4C member), Stephanie Plamondon (NMD4C member), Xavier Rodrigue (NMD4C member), Christen Shoesmith, Jodi Warman Chardon (NMD4C steering committee member), Bernard Brais (NMD4C investigator), and Lawrence Korngut (NMD4C investigator)

 

Frequency of monitoring

The natural history of SMA is a slowly progressive functional decline. Patients’ function decreases by a statistically significant amount in the matter of years, not months. As such, any decline in outcome measure scores in the span of months is more likely to be due to to inter- or intra-examiner variability (i.e., the normal statistical range of error) or variability in patient effort (i.e., SMA patients have “off days” and “good days” just like anyone else) than due to a true effect of the therapy. This potential artificial decline in outcome measure scores could lead to inappropriate termination of therapy provision.

Human resource strain and patient burden

Motor outcome assessments are time-consuming and personnel-intensive, requiring significant time from physical therapists and/or respiratory therapists with specialized training. As such, there are ethical concerns around mandating that these scarce resources be utilized to provide frequent monitoring for largely stable patients for whom such frequent monitoring is not clinically relevant or evidence-based. Frequent clinic visits can also be fatiguing, time-consuming, and costly for patients.

Collection of real-world evidence and proposition for appropriate monitoring

The Canadian Neuromuscular Disease Registry (CNDR) has a clear plan to assess the effectiveness of novel therapies in a broad population. The CNDR’s SMA working group of expert investigators is currently evaluating specific outcome assessments by way of a Delphi model to determine best practices (manuscript in preparation). They recently agreed that the best timing for outcome measurements is: at baseline, 6 months later, then annually thereafter. This timing is appropriate for clinical monitoring, congruent with available evidence in treated adults, and does not put undue burden on provincial and clinical resources or on patients and families.

The shared goal of the health care system is to provide a standard of care which is acceptable for patients, maintains appropriate resource allocation for all populations, and is feasible for the clinics. The proposed monitoring system achieves these goals.

writing-1149962_1920

Read next...

CIHR logo

NMD4C members awarded CIHR grants for oculopharyngeal dystrophy, spinal muscular atrophy research

The NMD4C is happy to share that two project applications from NMD4C members on oculopharyngeal dystrophy (OPMD) and spinal muscular atrophy (SMA)  have been awarded Canadian Institute of Health Research (CIHR) research grants in their recent round of funding decisions!

1x1Fellowship teaser

MDC & NMD4C Fellowship Funding Awards Coming Soon

The NMD4C in partnership with Muscular Dystrophy Canada (MDC) are excited to share that we will be launching a competition later this year to award funding for two postdoctoral research and two clinical fellowships! 

2021-SMAAM-Graphic

August is SMA Awareness Month: See What’s Happening Around the Community

August is Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) awareness month, and the NMD4C would like to take this time to recognize the work that our members and partners have contributed over the past year. While the network is involved in SMA-related activities year-round, August provides an opportunity to highlight this work and the impact it has on those affected by SMA.

Opportunity-uOttawaPhD

Research Opportunity: PhD in Translational Mitochondrial/Stem-Cell Research at the uOttawa Centre for Neuromuscular Disease

The NMD4C are excited to share a new research opportunity in Translational Mitochondrial/Stem-Cell Research at the uOttawa Centre for Neuromuscular Disease. The research team is looking for a talented PhD student who is interested in studying how impairments in mitochondrial dynamics and function alter the metabolic profile and maintenance of muscle stem cells in patients with rare mitochondrial and neuromuscular diseases.

EPIC_DM

Myotonic Dystrophy: EPIC Functions at The Ottawa Hospital

Inspired by a DM family from Ottawa, The Ottawa Hospital (TOH) medical information team has designed a new Best Practice Advisories (BPA) for their electronic health record system EPIC, to keep DM patients safe throughout the hospital. 

2x3ENMC

European Neuromuscular Centre Themed Workshops

The NMD4C is excited to share that the European Neuromuscular Centre (ENMC) has announced a new initiative: Themed Workshops! The call for organisers who would like to apply for an ENMC workshop on this theme is now open and will run until September 30, 2021.